Fanslations have always been an iffy business for me. On one hand, people in the TCG want to know what future awaits in the Western meta, thus encouraging them to translate up and coming OCG cards. Unfortunately, unless the translation was done a professional, which in most cases it isn't, a lot of things can be lost in translation.
Why do I bring this up?
Well, while browsing Pojo Forums, as I typically do on occasion, I came across a post by Kevin Tewart, whom most know as Konami's current U.S. head of development for the Yu-Gi-Oh! Trading Card Game. The post was a respond to a previous post about a player referring to the Exceed Monster known as No. 17 Revise Dragon:
Leviathan Dragon. It's Leviathan Dragon, not "revise dragon".
This is another example of how naming things in English, but using Japanese characters, doesn't really work that well. In many cases the English name is the correct name, since the real name is, well, English.
"Exceeds monster" is another such misnomer.
Exceed Monster is a misnomer? I don't know about everyone else, but every time I've watched an episode of Zexal, I distinctly hear エクシ一ズ (Ekushīzu). So naturally I was confused upon hearing this and didn't understand what he meant until I saw the advertisment for Starter Deck 2011 on Toywiz:
Name: Yu-Gi-Oh 2011 Dawn of the XYZManufacturer: KonamiSeries: YuGiOh ZEXALRelease Date: May 2011For ages: 4 and upDetails (Description): Exciting times are upon us for the Yu-Gi-Oh! property. There’s a brand new Yu-Gi-Oh! animated series on the horizon, and with it comes an all new kind of monster! These revolutionary monsters will make their spectacular North American debut in the 2011 Starter Deck. The 2011 Starter Deck serves two roles. It’s designed to teach new players the ins & outs of the Yu-Gi-Oh! TCG. It’s also to teach current players about this brand new category of monsters. And it’s the first place for Duelists to get their hands on these hot new monsters. The first booster set with the new monsters will be releasing in August 2011. But Duelists who want to be ahead of the game will get a leap forward by picking up their new monsters in this Starter Deck!
Each Starter Deck Contains: 40 Common Cards, 1 Ultra Rare Card, 2 Super Rare Cards, 1 Beginner’s Guide, 1 Game Mat – Plus the debut of the new Xyz monsters!
*Notes: Picture is a Konami placeholder, not final image!
Xyz Monsters? WTH! If this is accurate, which it may or may not be knowing Toywiz's track record, this would be one of the worst name changes ever. And to make matters worse they changed No. 39 Aspiring Emperor Hope to Number 39: Utopia? Much less dramatic than I'd have hoped. -__-
I'm at a loss for words.
Remember players, the game ends with you.
[blogpost]For ages: 4 and up[/quoting from above blogpost]
ReplyDelete-.-
Nomenclature fail!!! It's bad enough that toywiz has completely de-epicified No. 39's name but to translate Exceed as XYZ!? If this translation turns out to be official that will completely undermine the entire CONCEPT of exceed summoning. The process of exceed summoning in ZEXAL is called overlaying which, in the context of the original naming convention, makes sense since by overlaying one creature on top of another you are in essence summoning in EXCESS of the original material. If the name is changed to "XYZ" what on earth are we supposed to call the process of summoning now? ALPHABETIZING perhaps? HA! I swear localization is one of the great plagues of international business relations!
ReplyDeletewhat a terrible lolcalization.
ReplyDeleteUtopia. really.
Starting from the appearance of Ymna, yugioh suddenly changes from an adult/teenager game to a 3-year-old kid game.
ReplyDeleteXYZ monster is an extreme FAIL.
Utopia I can almost live with, but Xyz monsters? That's not even a word.
ReplyDelete*writes complaints to Konami*
~Valafar123
No.?? Broken Email Complano
ReplyDeleteDIVINE
Rank 13.3
Divine-Beast/Exceed
Copies said complaints to Konami 9001 times for every "Number" monster.
??????/??????
better not be XYZ, that is such a horrible name!!
ReplyDeleteUtopia isn't a bad name, but it's a place and would fit in a set like that of The Big Saturn, Supremacy Sun, etc., but this was originally an Emperor. You can't turn an Emperor into a Utopia.
ReplyDelete